InsurVibe
Quotes
🛡️Term life💗Critical illness🏠Home🚗Auto✈️Travel🏢Condo🔑Renters🐾Pet
ToolsGuidesInsightsNews
Log in
Insurance products
  • Term life
  • Critical illness
  • Home
  • Auto
  • Travel
  • Condo
  • Renters
  • Pet
Resources
  • Learning hub
  • Calculators
  • Insights
  • Cities
  • Household profiles
  • Search
  • FAQ
  • News
  • Sitemap
Popular
  • Average Toronto Renters Insurance Cost 2026
  • Average Toronto Condo Insurance Cost 2026
  • Average Toronto Home Insurance Cost 2026
  • Auto Insurance Rates 2026
  • Average Regina Home Insurance Cost 2026
Company
  • About us
  • Contact
  • For brokers
Legal & compliance
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Accessibility
© 2026 InsurVibe. All rights reserved.
Estimates, not final premiums — final pricing is set by the insurer
HomeGuidesQuoteInsightsMe
← Back to insights
Business risk

Comparing two participating whole life illustrations: an IA vs Desjardins case at age 24

Use a 24-year-old’s example to compare premiums, cash value, death benefits and non-guaranteed dividends in iA and Desjardins participating whole life illustrations.

Have two participating whole life illustrations and wonder where to start? This example follows a 24-year-old woman to explain the premiums, potential cash value, protection for beneficiaries and effect of changing dividends. These figures are projections for one set of circumstances, not a promise of your results.

1. Start by lining up the inputs

The case: a woman aged 24, non-smoker, CA$1,000,000 of coverage, 20 years of payments, CA$17,690 a year in total (CA$353,800 paid in all), with dividends buying paid-up additions. One illustration is iA’s Estate version, the other Desjardins’ Patrimoine bonifié, both prepared on November 12, 2026.

The total annual premiums match, but the coverage is not identical: iA lists CA$17,420 in base premium plus CA$270 for accidental death coverage; the Desjardins illustration does not list that rider separately. Ask your advisor to confirm the coverage, riders and costs before comparing; equal premiums alone do not make the plans identical.

Two mismatches are worth stating up front. The birth dates differ by a day (March 19 vs 18), but the insurance age is 24 either way. The tax-rate assumptions also differ (iA 53.5%, Desjardins 50%), which affects the tax pages only, not the cash and death values below.

📊 Female 24 · CA$1,000,000 · 20 pay · CA$17,690/yr · CA$353,800 in total

2. Cash value: four key ages

Take four ages: 44 (year 20, just fully paid), 66 (year 42, retirement), 85 (year 61) and 100 (year 76). On the current dividend scale, iA shows CA$472,993, 1,875,717, 5,474,216 and 11,384,538; Desjardins shows CA$401,342, 1,853,152, 5,394,624 and 10,760,250. iA is higher at all four points, by CA$71,651, 22,565, 79,592 and 624,288.

Don’t focus only on the largest number: the gap at 66 is CA$22,565, about 1.2%; it reaches CA$624,288 at 100. Consider which age matters to you and ask about the conditions and possible tax consequences of surrendering or borrowing.

📊 Current scale: iA’s cash value is higher at 44, 66, 85 and 100

3. Death benefit: the direction reverses

Switch the same comparison to death benefit and the direction flips. At 44, iA shows CA$1,690,186 against Desjardins’ 1,780,569, so Desjardins is CA$90,383 higher. At 66 Desjardins leads by CA$246,994 (3,749,187 vs 3,502,193); at 85 they’re nearly level, Desjardins ahead by CA$15,570. At 100 each death benefit equals its own cash value and iA is CA$624,288 higher again.

Cash value alone misses the protection for your beneficiaries. If leaving money to them is your priority, the death benefit may matter more; if you may surrender the policy, consider the cash value and its conditions. These figures generally are not two amounts payable together.

📊 Death benefit: Desjardins is higher at 44, 66 and 85; widest at 66 by CA$246,994

4. A 1% dividend cut: long-term results are the most sensitive

Both illustrations include a “dividend scale −1%” scenario. At 100, iA’s cash value falls from CA$11,384,538 to 6,066,124 (−46.7%) and Desjardins’ from 10,760,250 to 5,819,143 (−45.9%): both lose nearly half, by similar proportions. iA remains higher at 44, 66, 85 and 100 under the lower scale (by CA$75,569, 44,865, 52,765 and 246,981).

This shows how non-guaranteed values change with the dividend assumptions. Ask your advisor to identify guaranteed values alongside the current and lower dividend scenarios; actual future dividends may differ from either illustration.

📊 Dividend −1%: age-100 cash value iA −46.7%, Desjardins −45.9%

5. “Couldn’t I just invest this myself?”

You can also consider investing. This illustration invests CA$17,690 at the start of each year for 20 years, then stops, assuming a non-registered account and BC’s 2026 top marginal rates (53.5% on interest and 26.75% on capital gains). This is simplified: your tax rates, account, fees and actual returns may differ. At 6% before tax:

If all returns are taxed annually as interest, the values at 44, 66, 85 and 100 are CA$478,295, 876,223, 1,478,022 and 2,233,284. At 44 this exceeds both illustrated cash values; at the other three ages it is lower than both.

If the return is entirely deferred capital gain, taxed only when sold, it is CA$599,906, 1,915,382, 5,603,474 and 13,296,878, above both policies’ cash values at all four ages.

Change the return and the answer changes: at 4% before tax with deferred gains, the example gives CA$495,938, 1,045,682, 2,098,340 and 3,703,189 at those ages. The investment account itself has no additional death benefit; comparable insurance would require considering its cost and insurability. These simplified scenarios exclude that cost, investment fees, inflation and individual tax differences, so they cannot establish which choice is best for you.

📊 The comparison depends on returns, tax, costs and the death benefit you need

6. Five questions to ask about your illustrations

Do the age, smoking status, coverage, payment period, riders and dividend options match?

Is my priority protecting my family, leaving a legacy, or possibly using cash value later?

Which values are guaranteed, and what happens if dividends fall?

If I invest instead, what assumptions apply to returns, tax, fees and separate insurance?

When was the illustration prepared, and should it be updated if my circumstances or the insurer’s assumptions change?

7. Next: start with your own coverage needs

Start with how much coverage you need, how long you need it, and whether the premiums fit your long-term budget.

Already have a policy? Use InsurVibe’s policy review to explore its coverage and limitations, or start with a premium estimate to explore other options.

Ask a licensed advisor for current illustrations based on your age, health, goals and budget, and discuss applicable tax consequences with a tax professional.

📊 Identify your needs → understand coverage → compare personal illustrations

8. Bottom line

In this case iA’s cash value is higher, Desjardins’ death benefit is higher at the middle ages, and the gaps stay in the same range under a lower dividend scale. That doesn’t prove one is “better”, because each insurer’s dividend, expense and mortality assumptions differ and an illustration is not a promise. What is useful is the method: line up the inputs, read both measures, include the downside case, and answer the “invest it yourself” question honestly.

FAQ

Can I treat the illustration figures as expected returns?+

No. An illustration may contain both guaranteed values and values based on non-guaranteed dividends and other assumptions. Distinguish the two; non-guaranteed projections are not promised returns.

Why look at the “dividend −1%” case?+

Because long-term numbers are very sensitive to the dividend scale: in this case the age-100 cash value nearly halves after a one-point cut. Looking at the current scale alone overstates certainty.

Is investing the premium always better than the policy?+

Not necessarily. Returns, taxes, investment fees and coverage needs all matter; this simplified example does not deduct the cost of separate insurance. Compare options for your circumstances, including insurability.

Can this example replace my own illustration?+

No. Your premiums and coverage depend on your circumstances, underwriting and the insurer’s terms. Ask a licensed advisor for a current personal illustration that distinguishes guaranteed and non-guaranteed values.

Sources

  1. [1]iA Financial Group, iA Participating Life Insurance, Estate version, illustration, 20-year payment (prepared 2026-11-12) · 2026-11-12
  2. [2]Desjardins Insurance, Vie entière avec participation payable 20 ans, Patrimoine bonifié, illustration (prepared 2026-11-12) · 2026-11-12
  3. [3]InsurVibe, Comparison table and investment analysis built from the two illustrations · 2026-11-12
Get my accurate quote →
Estimate insurance costs
Explore approximate costs for your own coverage needs.
Understand your existing policy
Upload a policy to explore its coverage and possible limitations.
More insights
Segregated funds by province: probate fees and creditor protection in BC, AB, SK, MB and ON
From $0 to $14,250 on a $1M estate — and why Ontario is the only one of the five without provincial RRSP creditor protection
2026 Canadian insurance rate trends
Premiums compared across age, city and province
Senior travel insurance: the 65th-birthday cliff that is not there
We pulled real carrier quotes and re-priced our own engine: 55 and 65 cost about the same. What travel medical insurance really costs after 60
2026 auto rate hikes: who is hit hardest
What is behind AB +21.3% and ON +11.8%, and how to respond
Why 42% of Canadians have no life insurance
Price, misconceptions, or distribution?
Does commercial insurance cover fraud losses?
What a real card-fraud case revealed about coverage limits — and what risk control has to do instead
Real policy teardown: 6 details inside a $2,438 Unica Ontario home policy
A Pickering home and two rented Toronto condos — what the carrier actually priced in, line by line
Ontario home insurance repricing in 2026: what a 14% gap above the median tells us
How rental exposure, wood-frame rebuild costs and deductibles push premiums up — and what to check before renewal
Insurance products, news, deals & insights

2 emails a week: rate moves, regulation and money-saving tips. Unsubscribe anytime.

You are subscribed right away — we send a short notice you can unsubscribe from at any time.