Three police services, three different cities on one map: Barrie PS 9.82 / 27.83, South Simcoe (Alcona) 6.28 / 14.74, and the OPP detachments around Midhurst and Angus lower still (3.60 / 9.53 and 6.07 / 11.51). Plain-language reading of the 2026 crime and insurance data for Barrie.
In Barrie, crime and insurance cost do not always point the same way. Here is what the 2026 data show, and how to read them without being misled.
Three police services, three different cities on one map: Barrie PS 9.82 / 27.83, South Simcoe (Alcona) 6.28 / 14.74, and the OPP detachments around Midhurst and Angus lower still (3.60 / 9.53 and 6.07 / 11.51).
The lakeshore takes the water risk: Innis-Shore and Alcona carry high flood grades on Kempenfelt Bay / Lake Simcoe, with Angus high on the Nottawasaga.
No theft-from-vehicle rate is published by any of the three services — the column is grey across the whole map rather than filled with a substitute basket.
Metro-wide, police-reported crime per 1,000 residents a year: persons 9.82, property 27.83, vehicle theft 1.39, break-in 1.24 (total), theft from vehicles not published. These are the jurisdiction-level rates behind the community table, and each is counted on the basis the police service uses.
Auto premium: $2,412 — basis: Rates.ca avg quote — Barrie, 2026-03. Home premium: $2,261 — basis: Rates.ca avg quote — Barrie, 2026 Q2. Premiums here are city-level figures on the basis named, not quotes for any one home or driver.
In the community table, Innis-Shore, Alcona, Angus carry the highest flood or sewer-backup grade. These grades are are mostly inferred from housing age, elevation and published floodplain mapping, so read them as a guide to ask about, not a verdict on a single house.
Every row is a jurisdiction proxy — none of the three services publishes community counts. Break-in is the total.
Barrie and Innisfil share the same Rates.ca auto quote ($2,412) in the source table; home quotes differ ($2,261 / $2,303).
Ontario auto insurers file their own postal-code territories and the relativities are not public, so a city figure is a quoted average, not a tariff. All Ontario auto figures here predate the July 1, 2026 reform that made several accident benefits optional, so coverage has changed since. For a home, ask whether sewer backup and overland water are included; standard Canadian policies exclude both unless you buy the endorsements.
Not directly. The map shows the two often point in different directions. Three police services, three different cities on one map: Barrie PS 9.82 / 27.83, South Simcoe (Alcona) 6.28 / 14.74, and the OPP detachments around Midhurst and Angus lower still (3.60 / 9.53 and 6.07 / 11.51).
All 10 rows are flagged as proxies: they carry the rate of their police jurisdiction rather than a count for that neighbourhood, because full neighbourhood counts are not published. That is a jurisdiction background, not a neighbourhood ranking, and the warnings above spell out exactly which columns are borrowed.
Grey or a dash means no public data. The map leaves those cells empty rather than estimating them, so a gap is not the same as low risk.
2 emails a week: rate moves, regulation and money-saving tips. Unsubscribe anytime.
You are subscribed right away — we send a short notice you can unsubscribe from at any time.